March 28
0 comments
Share this
Is ADHD just a modern invention or a convenient label for everyday distraction?
Critics often argue that attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) is overdiagnosed, socially constructed, or simply a trendy excuse for poor behavior. But historical records tell a different story—one that stretches back more than a century.
In fact, as early as 1904, renowned psychiatrist Carl Gustav Jung was documenting patient cases that eerily resemble what we now recognize as adult ADHD.
In a groundbreaking 2025 study published in the Journal of Attention Disorders, researchers at the University of Leipzig analyzed Jung's early psychiatric work and found striking parallels to today's diagnostic criteria for ADHD.
Jung's essay, titled "Über manische Verstimmungen" ("On Manic Moods"), presented four case studies involving adults with persistent symptoms such as impulsivity, emotional dysregulation, restlessness, distractibility, and difficulty with long-term focus - all hallmarks of ADHD.
At the time, Jung labeled these symptoms as signs of a "chronic submanic state" or "constitutional manic mood," and he carefully differentiated them from conditions like bipolar disorder or moral insanity.
One of Jung's patients, for example, was a nurse who changed jobs 32 times in 11 years, exhibited chronic restlessness, made impulsive decisions, and had a history of mood swings.
Another was a merchant who was brilliant but disorganized, emotionally volatile, and prone to abandoning projects midstream - classic ADHD behavior.
What makes this revelation so compelling is how closely these 1904 case descriptions match the modern symptom profile outlined in the DSM-5.
Jung even noted the early onset of symptoms in childhood and how they persisted into adulthood—long before ADHD was formally recognized as a diagnosis.
These early descriptions also align with current understandings of comorbid conditions like emotional dysregulation and substance misuse.
This historical continuity undermines the argument that ADHD is a recent invention or a cultural trend.
While the terminology and diagnostic criteria have evolved, the clinical reality has not.
The condition we now call ADHD has been observed, recorded, and struggled with for over a century, even if it went by different names.
Jung’s documentation supports the view that ADHD is a stable and enduring neurodevelopmental condition, not a fleeting trend.
Acknowledging the deep historical roots of ADHD is more than an academic exercise; it shifts public discourse away from skepticism and toward understanding.
It helps validate the lived experiences of millions of adults who were misunderstood or misdiagnosed for decades. It also reinforces the need for accessible diagnosis and support, especially for adults whose symptoms have persisted since childhood.
The next time someone claims that ADHD is just a fad, tell them Carl Jung might disagree.
Loved this? Spread the word
What happens when ADHD is recognised after you’ve already built a life? If you met me in person and, somewhere along the way, we found ourselves talking about ADHD (fair warning…this is not a short conversation), you would very quickly notice my particular fixation on late diagnosis, and my less-than-subtle view that the professional class—clinicians
Read MoreWhat a massive genetics study tells us—and what it still can’t explain Every few years a study comes along that quietly shifts the ground beneath psychiatry. Not with a headline like “We’ve found the ADHD gene” (we haven’t), but with something more unsettling:| What if the way we divide mental health conditions doesn’t match how the brain
Read MoreShort-term trials can’t measure long-term change—and people with ADHD pay the price. A new umbrella review in The BMJ tries to answer a deceptively simple question: what actually works for ADHD?Not in theory, not in opinion—but across hundreds of randomised trials and decades of research. The authors analysed 221 re-estimated meta-analyses covering 31 interventions across preschoolers, children, adolescents, and adults. It’s one of the most comprehensive
Read MoreUnderstanding how ADHD identity harms, heals, and helps us make sense of who we are. If you spend any time around critical psychiatry, you’ll know the script:“ADHD as an identity is harmful. It locks people into a sick role, it feeds social media trends, and it turns ordinary struggle into pathology.”It’s a serious concern. And there are real risks
Read More